Reddit

Ripping you off Stage 3

Old Reddit’s community scale is real; new Reddit’s interface and API drama show extraction: third-party clients curtailed, ads more prominent, and moderation burden pushed to volunteers. Shutting off RSS and ending public API access (2026–27) while selling data to AI firms finishes the enclosure. Still usable, but the surplus has clearly moved toward business customers and shareholders—classic stage 3.

The promise

Its first promise, and how much is kept · Scoring

60% kept

“reddit learns what you like as you vote on existing links or submit your own!”
reddit homepage, 2007 2 extraction criteria met.

Why it’s rated 3

The criteria it meets, with sources · Method

Alignment 0 of 3
None
Lock-in 1 of 4
  • L1 Network or reputation
Extraction 2 of 7
Decline 0 of 3
None

Result Two or more extraction criteria, or lock-in plus at least one, so stage 3.

News signals

Sourced reporting, tagged by strategy