Hipcamp

Watch out Stage 2

Hipcamp connects campers with private landowners who open their land for overnight stays—a market the hotel OTAs ignore. Host fees are lower than Airbnb’s, and its value depends on keeping landowners willing to list. Hosts’ reviews don’t move with them, though, and nothing structural protects users from the incentive to extract. Stage 2.

The promise

Its first promise, and how much is kept · Scoring

100% kept

“Discover great camping spots near you”
Hipcamp homepage, 2015 No extraction or decline criteria met.

Why it’s rated 2

The criteria it meets, with sources · Method

Alignment 0 of 3
None
Lock-in 1 of 4
  • L1 Network or reputation
Extraction 0 of 7
None
Decline 0 of 3
None

Result No extraction that meets the stage 3 test, and either some lock-in or no alignment criterion, so stage 2.

Rating history

Oct 6, 2026
Downgraded 1 Worth it → 2 Watch out

Rescored under Method 2.1. No extraction criterion is documented in the last three years. Lock-in (L1 Network or reputation) keeps it at stage 2.